Last Updated on November 10, 2026 by Sam Wood Worker

Maple vs. Cherry Wood: Which One Is Actually Better?

Quick Answer: Neither wood is better in every case. Hard maple is harder, lighter in color, and better for heavy-wear items like workbenches, cutting boards, and floors. Cherry is softer, easier to work, and famous for its rich reddish color that deepens with age. It is a favorite for furniture and cabinets. Pick maple for toughness. Pick cherry for warmth and character.

Key Takeaways

  • Hard maple is much harder than cherry: about 1,450 lbf vs about 950 lbf on the Janka scale.
  • Cherry starts light pinkish-brown and slowly darkens to a deep reddish brown. Maple stays pale cream to light tan.
  • Both have a fine, smooth grain.
  • Maple can stain unevenly. Cherry can blotch too. Test your stain first.
  • Cherry is usually easier to cut and shape. Maple can burn and dull tools faster.
  • “Maple” can mean hard or soft maple. They are not the same.
  • Always follow the manufacturer’s finish instructions and your local building requirements.

The Short Version: Side-by-Side

FeatureHard MapleBlack Cherry
Janka hardness (approx.)About 1,450 lbfAbout 950 lbf
ColorCream to light tanPinkish-brown, darkens to deep red-brown
GrainFine, close, often straightFine, smooth, often straight
Dent resistanceHighMedium
Ease of workingHarder on tools, can burnCuts and shapes easily
StainingCan blotchCan blotch, often finished with clear coats
AgingStays light, may yellow slightlyDarkens noticeably with light
Typical costVaries by region and gradeVaries by region and grade
Best forFloors, workbenches, cutting boards, butcher blocksFurniture, cabinets, trim, fine pieces

Janka numbers differ a little between sources, so treat them as a guide. Prices change by region and grade, so compare local quotes. In many markets, cherry costs more than hard maple, but this is not always true.

Cherry Wood

What Is Hard Maple?

Hard maple, also called sugar maple, is a dense North American hardwood. Sapwood is very light. Heartwood can be darker and slightly reddish. It is substantially harder than soft maple and ranks close to 1,400 on the Janka scale.

Be careful with the word “maple.” “Soft maple” is not a separate species. It is a trade term used to separate certain maples from hard maple. Soft maple is usually closer in hardness to cherry. The Wood Database article on the differences between hard and soft maple explains this well.

Maple also has special figured types, like quilted maple, curly maple, and birdseye maple.

What Is Cherry Wood?

In woodworking, “cherry” usually means American black cherry (Prunus serotina). It is not the same as fruit-bearing cherry trees. Black cherry is commonly listed at about 950 on the Janka scale.

Fresh cherry is light pinkish-brown. With time and light, it darkens into a deep, warm reddish brown. Many people love this aging. Others find it surprising if they expected the original color to stay.

cherry wood Furniture

Hardness and Durability

Maple wins on hardness. At about 1,450 lbf, hard maple resists dents far better than cherry at about 950 lbf. If the surface will get hit, scraped, or walked on, maple has an edge.

That said, cherry is not weak. It is used for fine furniture and cabinets that last for decades. It will dent more easily than maple, but many people accept that for the look.

Janka only measures dent resistance. It does not tell you strength, screw holding, or how stable the wood is. The USDA Wood Handbook is a good reference for those properties.

For more on very hard woods, see our guide to white oak.

Color and Looks

Maple is bright and clean. It suits modern, Scandinavian, and light, airy styles. It also takes paint and light stains well when done carefully.

Cherry is warm and rich. It suits traditional, Shaker, Colonial, and classic styles. Its color changes over time, so a new cherry table will look different in a few years.

If you place cherry beside a sunny window, expect faster darkening on the exposed areas. Rotating items on a shelf or table can help it age more evenly.

Working With Maple vs Cherry

Cherry cuts, planes, and sands smoothly. It is a pleasure for hand tools and machines. It can burn if your blades are dull or you feed too slowly.

Maple is dense. It can burn easily with dull blades, and it can wear tools faster. Sharp blades and a steady feed help. If you plane maple, review our thickness planer mistakes.

Both glue well when surfaces are clean and fit tightly. Our wood glue guide covers the basics.

Staining and Finishing

2

This is where many people get surprised.

Maple: It is known for blotching, especially with dark stains. Many woodworkers use a wood conditioner, a gel stain, or a light dye. Some prefer a clear finish that keeps the natural pale look.

Cherry: It can blotch too, and it can look uneven if stained. Many people use a clear finish so the wood can darken naturally. If you do stain it, test on scrap first.

For both woods:

  1. Sand evenly through the grits and remove all dust.
  2. Use a pre-stain conditioner if you plan to stain.
  3. Test the finish on a spare piece from the same board.
  4. Follow the product label for drying and recoating.

Helpful guides: wood finish basics, fixing blotchy stain, water-based polyurethane, wipe-on poly, and hardwax oil vs Danish oil. For furniture oils, see the best oil for wood furniture.

Want a modern color? Read about gray wood stain and black wood stain. Maple usually handles these shades better than cherry, but test first.

Best Uses for Maple

  • Cutting boards and butcher blocks. Maple is a classic choice because it is hard and has a tight grain. If you use glue, pick one rated food safe. See food-safe wood glue.
  • Workbenches and heavy tabletops.
  • Flooring. Many gyms and homes use maple floors.
  • Kitchen cabinets with a light, clean look.
  • Musical instruments and tool handles.
  • Modern furniture.

Best Uses for Cherry

  • Fine furniture. Tables, chairs, dressers, and beds.
  • Cabinets and built-ins. See our guide to raised panel cabinet doors.
  • Trim and millwork.
  • Decorative boxes and carved pieces.
  • Pieces where aging color is a feature.

Neither wood is a good choice for outdoor use. Both need protection from moisture, so keep them indoors or follow strict finishing and care guidelines. For outdoor projects, see our best woods for decks.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose maple if:

  • The item will see heavy use, like a kitchen table, workbench, or butcher block.
  • You want a light, bright, modern look.
  • Dent resistance matters most.

Choose cherry if:

  • You want a warm, classic look that deepens with age.
  • You prefer easier cutting and shaping.
  • The piece is for furniture or cabinets with moderate wear.

Consider other options if:

  • You want a cherry look at a lower price. Alder can be stained to look similar. Read our alder wood guide.
  • You want a light wood with a different feel. Compare birch.
  • You want to compare more species. Start with our guide to types of wood.

Buying Tips

  • Ask whether the maple is hard or soft. The price and hardness differ.
  • Check the grade. Clear boards cost more. Our wood grades guide explains how to read them.
  • For cherry, ask about sapwood. Cherry boards may include pale sapwood next to dark heartwood. This can look uneven in some projects.
  • Check moisture. Indoor lumber should be dry. A moisture meter helps.
  • Match boards by color. Cherry especially varies from board to board before it darkens.
  • Buy extra. Defects and cut-offs use up wood.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Assuming all maple has the same hardness.
  • Staining maple dark without a conditioner or test piece.
  • Expecting cherry to keep its fresh color forever.
  • Using either wood outdoors without proper protection.
  • Choosing cherry for a very heavy-use work surface.
  • Not sharpening blades before cutting maple, which can cause burn marks.
  • Skipping the manufacturer’s instructions on finishes and glues.

Final Thoughts

Maple and cherry are both excellent hardwoods. Maple is tougher and brighter. Cherry is warmer and easier to work. Choose based on how the piece will be used and the look you want, not on which wood has the bigger reputation.

Before you buy, check your supplier’s specs and the finish maker’s instructions, and follow your local building requirements. This article is research-based and not a substitute for professional advice.

FAQ

Is maple stronger than cherry?
Hard maple is harder and more dent-resistant than cherry. Overall strength depends on the board and the use, so check supplier data for structural needs.

Which is more expensive, maple or cherry?
In many markets cherry costs more than hard maple, but prices vary by region, grade, and thickness. Compare local quotes.

Does cherry wood darken over time?
Yes. Cherry slowly turns from light pinkish-brown to a deeper reddish brown, mostly from light exposure.

Is maple good for kitchen cabinets?
Yes, especially for a light, clean look. It is hard, so it handles daily use well. Stain carefully to avoid blotching.

Which is better for a dining table, maple or cherry?
Maple resists dents better. Cherry gives a warmer look but marks more easily. Either one works with a tough clear finish. See our best finish for wooden dining tables.

Is hard maple the same as soft maple?
No. Hard maple is denser and harder. Soft maple is easier to work and often closer to cherry in hardness.

Can I use maple or cherry outdoors?
It is not recommended. Both are better kept indoors unless you follow strict protection and maintenance guidance.

By Sam Wood Worker

Sam is the founder of The Wood Carpenter and a woodworking and decking enthusiast. He creates research-based guides using manufacturer documentation, product specifications, recognized industry resources and practical project information. Facebook | Instagram